October 2008

October 2008

Higher education expands rapidly in OECD countries

Some of the main findings of Education at a Glance 2008, the latest annual report from the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) are the following:

  • The higher education sector has expanded rapidly worldwide over the past decade. In the 30 OECD countries, 57% of school-leavers, on average, went to university in 2005, compared to 37% in 1995.
  • In Australia, Finland, Iceland, Poland and Sweden, three out of every four school-leavers go on to a degree course.
  • Public expenditure on higher education has increased, but private investment has risen even more.
  • The share of public funds spent on higher education has expanded from 11.9% in 1995 to 13.2% in 2005, while average private spending on higher education has nearly tripled in OECD member countries over the 2000-2005 period. However, there are wide variations with Denmark, Finland and Greece getting less than 5% of funds from the private sector, while in Australia, Canada, Japan, New Zealand and the US, the proportion is more than 40% and in Korea 75%.
  • Private funding of higher education can be influenced by the number of international students in the system. More than 2.9m students were enrolled in higher education institutions outside their own countries in 2005, double the number in 1995 and a 50% increase on 2000.
  • Tuition fees also vary among the 30 OECD countries. In the five Nordic countries, the Czech Republic, Ireland and Poland, public institutions do not charge tuition fees. In contrast, one-third of OECD member countries have annual fees in excess of US$1 500. In the US, fees for American students reach more than US$5 000, while among the 19 EU countries, only the Netherlands and the UK have annual tuition fees in excess of US$1 100 for a full time national student.
  • Social sciences, business and law are the most popular subjects in most OECD countries as they constituted 28% of the overall intake to universities in 2005.
  • Female students made up 54% of new entrants to OECD universities in 2005, but the breakdown of gender varied according to subjects. In health and welfare, the arts and humanities and education, between 68 and 75% of new students are women. The proportion of women choosing science, maths, computing, engineering, manufacturing, construction and agriculture ranges from less than 25% in Japan, the Netherlands, Spain and Switzerland to more than 35% in Denmark, Iceland, Italy and New Zealand.
  • Earnings increase with each level of qualification. On average across the 30 OECD countries, a degree yields a 12% return for men and 11% for women in the 25-64 age group.
  • Employment rates tend to drop long before the retirement age in most OECD countries, but rates increase with educational attainment in most, and in all countries except Iceland, higher educational qualifications make an important difference at an older age.
  • High completion rates are an indicator of educational efficiency. In the UK and Denmark, around 80% of degree students successfully complete their courses and in Japan more than 90% achieve this goal, which is well above the OECD average of 69%.


Pan-African Awards for Entrepreneurship in Education 2008 launched

A competition offering a first prize of US$10 000, two runner-up prizes of US$5 000 each and 50 other prizes of US$1 000 each for the best entrepreneurial education programme in each African country has recently been launched by the UK-based education charity, Teach A Man To Fish. The Educating Africa Pan-African Awards for Entrepreneurship in Education 2008 seeks to identify the very best organisations which have risen to the challenge of supporting education across Africa; to highlight their models; and to reward their achievements. The competition is open to all organisations based in Africa working in education, from primary through to tertiary, as well as in non-formal and adult education. According to Nik Kafka, managing director of Teach A Man To Fish, ‘if the huge demand for education that exists across Africa is to be met, it will require new and entrepreneurial models which can be replicated and taken to scale’.

Entries will be assessed against three criteria of entrepreneurship, sustainability and impact, and must be received before 20 Oct 2008. The winners will be selected by a panel of international judges, and the top three award-winners will be invited to collect their prizes at Education That Pays For Itself 2008, an international conference on sustainable education to be held in November 2008 in South Africa. Organisations wishing to take part should visit the competition website at www.teachamantofish.org.uk/competition for full details.


Three African universities in global top 500

In the 2008 Academic Ranking of World Universities, annually produced by the Institute of Higher Education at the Shanghai Jaio Tong University for the government of China, two African universities (ie, the Cairo University and the University of Pretoria ranked 406th and 486th respecrively in 2007) have slipped from the top 500 universities ranking, leaving only three African universities ranked in the elite global list for 2008, ie, the universities of Cape Town, the Witwatersrand and KwaZulu-Natal. South Africa follows Ireland in 25th place in terms of the percentage distribution of top universities by country, ahead of European countries such as Greece, Hungary, Poland and Portugal, as well as India. With three of its 23 public universities in the Top 500, South Africa has 13% of its tertiary institutions represented, and together the three universities enrol approximately 85 000 students. Of the three South African universities ranked among the top 500 universities in the world in 2008, the University of Cape Town is ranked highest, ie 252nd – the same ranking as in 2006 and one place higher than in 2007. Just beating the University of Cape Town are the University of Bologna in Italy, Bordeaux 1 in France and the University of Calgary in Canada. The University of the Witwatersrand is in 398th position, the same as in 2007 and two positions down from 2006. Ranked just above the University of the Witwatersrand, are the universities of Ulm in Germany, Valencia in Spain and Warsaw in Poland. The University of KwaZulu-Natal is in 477th position, down from 474th position in 2007 and 470th position in 2006. As a country, South Africa claims a meagre 0.6% of the top 500 places in the Academic Ranking of World Universities.

The US is first with 31.6% in terms of the percentage share of the top 500 universities by country, which is less that Europe combined, but way better than any other country in the world. More than half of the 100 universities ranked highest are American universities. The US is followed in the Top 500 by the UK with 8.3%, Germany (8%), Japan (6.2%), China (6%), France (4.6%), Italy (4.4%) and Canada (4.2%). Besides China, the only other developing country ranked ahead of South Africa is Brazil, which has a 1.2% share of universities in the Top 500. The University World News states that ‘[w]hile many universities and higher education sectors around the world ‘officially’ reject Shanghai’s Academic Ranking of World Universities, it has gathered sufficient momentum and academic credibility to demand that it is not ignored. South African universities will be concerned not to fall behind in the rankings race.’


Gender inequity prevails in many tertiary institutions in Africa

Focussing on access, curriculum transformation and staff development in higher education, new research by the Centre for Higher Education and Equity Research at the University of Sussex, UK, finds that gender inequity still prevails despite national and institutional support for equality. The study explored how far gender equity is promoted or inhibited in five higher education institutions in South Africa, Sri Lanka, Nigeria, Tanzania and Uganda. These countries were selected for their national policies on gender equity and commitment to international policies to end discrimination against women. The research has found that a highly-gendered environment exists which impedes women’s development as students and staff, having a negative effect on students’ learning and on female staff’s academic identities. According to the study, discriminatory practices include:

  • exclusion of women from career development opportunities;
  • gender-insensitive teaching practices;
  • sexual harassment and gender violence left unchecked;
  • prejudice concerning women’s academic abilities and intellectual authority;
  • poor implementation of gender equality policies; and
  • male domination of knowledge production, decision-making processes, and research opportunities.

The study suggests a range of approaches to encourage increased gender equity, including to:

  • adopt national implementation strategies for gender equity such as with targets, evaluation procedures and regular monitoring;
  • develop and support affirmative action programmes such as women-only management development programmes;
  • fund women to participate in international networks, seminars and conferences;
  • conduct organisational gender audits;
  • ensure effective institutional responses to discrimination, such as codes of practice and disciplinary measures; and
  • encourage women to attend staff development programmes and women’s studies courses.


Higher Education HIV/AIDS Programme (HEAIDS) launched in South Africa

Recently, the Higher Education HIV/AIDS Programme, funded by the EU to the amount of R220m, embarked on one of the biggest HIV-prevalence studies ever undertaken in South Africa. The study not only aims to determine the level of HIV infection among 25 000 randomly selected students and staff from all 23 higher education institutions in South Africa, but also to establish the knowledge, attitudes, perceptions and behaviour of students and staff regarding HIV/AIDS. According to Dr Mvuyo Tom, vice-chancellor of the University of Fort Hare, who is a member of the HEAIDS strategic advisory committee, ‘the youth is the most exposed group to HIV. If we want to deal with HIV, we must have programmes that mitigate the disease and reduce infection. We cannot treat what we can’t measure and this is why this study is important.’ Mahlubi Mabizela, director of higher education at the Department of Education, said it was important for the country to know what the prevalence of HIV is at tertiary level. ‘Students are a reflection of our society. Higher learning institutions produce the human resource to various sectors of our economy and it is important for us to know [what the rate of prevalence is] so we know what to do and how to allocate finances’.


Foundation-phase education in South Africa

At the recent Foundation Phase Conference, the Minister of Education, Naledi Pandor, stated that quality foundation-phase education is of critical importance in South Africa. ‘It is within the foundation-phase grades, Grades R-3, that basic literacy, numeracy and life skills are developed and advanced. In the foundation-phase learners must learn how to read, write, count and calculate confidently and with understanding.’ In 2007 a representative sample of more than 54 000 Grade 3 learners from more than 2 400 primary schools participated in the second cycle of the systemic evaluation survey in which the written foundational skills of literacy and numeracy of the learners were tested; the first cycle of the survey was done in 2001. According to Naledi Pandor, some of the key findings emerging from the survey are:

  • The average overall percentage score obtained by the learners in literacy was 36%, while that in numeracy was 35%. ‘Although the average score in the 2007 survey was a little higher than the baseline 2001 result that was 30%, clearly the scores are still unacceptably low’.
  • Achievement of learners in numeracy and literacy varied in relation to the language in which they took the test, which coincided with the language of instruction. English and Afrikaans learners fared better, with average numeracy scores of 48% and 49%, respectively, and average literacy scores of 43% and 48%, respectively. African language mother tongue speakers had lower average scores. For example, for Siswati and Xitsonga learners, the average numeracy scores were 24% and 20%, respectively. The average literacy score for both Siswati and Tshivenda learners was 26%.
  • The total number of learners who performed excellently in either literacy or numeracy or both (achieving a score of 70% or above) was 5 439, constituting only 10% of the total sample. In only 148 schools representing only 6% of the sample, performance was outstanding (learners achieved an average score of 70% or above) in either literacy or numeracy or both.

According to Naledi Pandor, ‘some of the clearly intertwined challenges we experience at the level of foundation-phase education include the problem of teacher quantity, quality and ability; lack of sufficient support for African language learners; large class sizes; lack of resources; lack of quality leadership in schools, and the like. They are the shaky ground upon which we build education for some of our learners, especially those in rural and poor areas. The situation must change.’


My 2010 School Adventure project

The My 2010 School Adventure project, an initiative of the 2010 FIFA World Cup Organising Committee South Africa and the national departments of education and sport and recreation, focuses on three key areas, viz, education, development of sport skills and coaching, and participation in regional and nationwide schools football tournaments. In the first phase, pupils and teachers will, as part of the curriculum, learn about the teams participating in the 2009 Confederations Cup and build relationships with schools in the countries that have qualified. Schools have already started playing in provincial football tournaments and the winning teams from all the provinces will play in the Schools Confederations Cup in March 2009. The national winning team will win tickets to attend the Confederations Cup, running from 14-28 June 2009 and featuring the current champions of the six FIFA Confederations, the reigning world champions and the next FIFA World Cup hosts, namely Brazil, Egypt, Iraq, Italy, New Zealand, the US, Spain, and the current host South Africa.

Recently, Education Minister Pandor launched a special schools project called Adopt a Nation, part of the My 2010 School Adventure, which will target 12m children from over 30 000 schools nationwide. ‘This schools project will see schools adopt the identity of nations participating in the Confederations Cup. This will provide an opportunity for schools to know more about the cultures of the people of the world’, she said. From Sept 2008 to Jan 2009, pupils across the country will work on creative elements such as essays, poetry, art projects, music and dance performances relating to the Confederations Cup, with the winning submission in line to win tickets to the Confederations Cup and the 2010 World Cup.


School evaluation

University of the Witwatersrand honorary education professor Jonathan Jansen has been appointed chairman of a ministerial committee on school evaluation. Early this year, the cabinet approved the establishment of a unit in the education department responsible for monitoring, evaluating and supporting schools and teachers. The committee’s central task would be to recommend to Education Minister Pandor mechanisms through which this could take place. The final report will be submitted to the minister by January 2009.

Back to top